Dispute Resolutions
Find the resources, forms, and support available for resolving disputes and ethics concerns within the real estate profession.
Official Resources & Contacts
-
California Association of REALTORS®
-
California Department of Real Estate
-
National Association of REALTORS®
-
Mediation Complaint Request
We suggest that you contact your local association of REALTORS® to request the proper forms required by that association.
Phone: (530) 223-0410
Email: ceo@shastaaor.com
Ethics / Disciplinary Action
-
Background
Associations of REALTORS® enforce the REALTORS® Code of Ethics, a set of duties beyond what law or regulation requires, applying only to those who choose to become REALTORS®.
Many disputes between real estate professionals stem from miscommunication rather than actual misconduct. If you have a concern, start by speaking directly with the professional or their principal broker. If that doesn't resolve things, contact the local association, many offer informal resolution options like an ombudsman or mediation. If you still have a grievance after that, you may consider filing a formal ethics complaint.
A few things to know before filing:
Only REALTORS® and REALTOR-ASSOCIATE®s are subject to the Code of Ethics. If the professional you're dealing with isn't a REALTOR®, your recourse may be the state licensing authority or the courts instead.
Associations determine whether the Code of Ethics was violated, not whether a law was broken; that determination belongs to licensing authorities or the courts.
Discipline for violations can include required courses, reprimands, fines, or suspension/termination of membership. Associations cannot award monetary damages to complainants or revoke a real estate license; the focus is primarily educational, with more serious discipline reserved for serious or repeated violations.
Filing an Ethics Complaint
Complaints must be filed within 180 days of when the conduct was, or reasonably should have been, discovered.
The Code of Ethics has 17 Articles. Your complaint must cite the specific Article(s) you believe were violated, hearing panels only decide on the Articles actually cited.
Include a narrative description of what happened. The Grievance Committee can help you prepare your complaint in proper form.
Code of Ethics: View the NAR Code of Ethics
Ethics Complaint form: Download the Ethics Complaint form, email to ceo@shastaaor.comDonna Medina, Chief Executive Officer, Shasta Association of REALTORS®
Before the Hearing
Your complaint is first reviewed by the Grievance Committee to determine whether, if your allegations are true, they would support a violation of the Article(s) you cited.
A dismissal doesn't mean they disbelieve you, it means your allegations wouldn't support that conclusion. You may want to revisit which Article you cited.
Forwarding your complaint to a hearing doesn't mean a violation has been found, only that it's worth the hearing panel's review.
If dismissed, you can appeal to the board of directors.
Arbitration Form
Duty and Privilege to Arbitrate
Arbitration isn't unique to real estate, many professions use it to resolve disputes. When a real estate licensee joins a local association like SAOR, they gain the rights of REALTOR® membership but also take on its obligations, including Article 17 of the Code of Ethics, which requires using arbitration to resolve disputes.
This obligation isn't limited to association members. Licensees who participate in the MLS also agree to abide by the MLS Rules and Regulations, which require arbitration for disputes arising from MLS listings, even for non-members.
Arbitration is contractual, parties agree to it in writing, either before or after a dispute arises. A member's written agreement to arbitrate comes from three sources: their signed membership application, their agreement to abide by the association's Bylaws, and their agreement to the Code of Ethics (specifically Article 17). This agreement exists at the time of joining and is simply repeated, not created, on arbitration complaint and response forms; failing to sign those forms doesn't remove the obligation.
Members may also agree to arbitrate disputes with their own clients, provided the client separately agrees in writing via the Client of Member Arbitration Complaint Form (Form PA-1), which also binds the client to comply with the arbitration award.
Operating under a corporation doesn't shield a member from arbitration. Both the C.A.R. membership application and the California Model Bylaws make clear that a member binds themselves and their corporation to arbitration. Associations may still request a corporate resolution authorizing this, ideally at the time a complaint is filed.
Members can agree to arbitrate disputes elsewhere instead (for example, in a listing or buyer's broker agreement); this is legal and takes precedence over arbitrating at the association. However, if a member bypasses arbitration by filing a civil lawsuit and the other party doesn't request the court compel arbitration, both parties effectively waive their right to arbitrate at the association, and neither is in violation of Article 17.
What Is an Ombudsman?
C.A.R. Ombudsmen are REALTORS® who volunteer their time to answer non-legal questions and resolve non-legal disputes, free of charge. An ombudsman is not an attorney and cannot give legal advice.
Is this confidential? License information is required to assign your case to an ombudsman, but they will not contact the other party unless you ask them to.
Who can use this service:
Members with a concern about another member's conduct, a transaction issue, or who just need peer advice
Consumers involved in an active transaction with a REALTOR® who have questions or a minor dispute, provided you are a C.A.R. member or the client of one
What you'll need to provide:
Your name, email, and phone number
Your license number (members) or your agent's license number (non-members)
For disputes, the other party's license number
A brief description of the topic